Andrew Garfield and Emma Stone dated from 2011 to 2015, and their breakup was attributed to everything from their busy schedules to Garfield being "in a dark place" while filming the historical drama "Silence." Stone later married comedian Dave McCary, while Garfield has dated several women over the years.

Andrew Garfield dated "Jessica Jones" actor Susie Abromeit for most of 2018, and later that year, he was linked to singer Rita Ora. Neither of them ever confirmed they were dating, but they were spotted out together on several occasions.

In early 2019, Garfield appeared to be dating Irish actor Aisling Bea, but in mid-2019, he started dating med student and model Christine Gabel, per Radar. He reportedly met the USC grad through friends and they hit it off, but in 2020, a source alleged that the relationship was "not right" for Garfield.