What's Come Out About Jussie Smollett's Attack

On Feb. 14, 2019, Good Morning America aired an exclusive interview between Jussie Smollett and host Robin Roberts. The actor tearfully defended his version of events and questioned skeptics. "It's not necessarily that you don't believe that this is the truth, you don't even want to see the truth," he said, suggesting race played a role in the way his story was received. He'd said the attackers were white. "It feels like if I had said it was a Muslim, or a Mexican, or someone black, I feel like the doubters would have supported me ... that says a lot about the place that we are in our country right now."

Smollett denied reports that he'd said his attackers were wearing President Donald Trump's signature MAGA hats. "I don't need some MAGA hat as the cherry on top of some racist sundae," he said. However, Smollett did say he believed he was targeted because he's been critical of Trump: "I come really, really hard against 45." 

According to The Blast, some GMA staffers had their doubts about the actor, noting that Smollett reportedly initiated contact with the morning show and "specifically requested" Roberts, who appeared on an episode of Empire in 2018. Roberts has since addressed that interview, reminding audiences that when she sat down with Smollett, "police officers were saying that his account was consistent, it was credible, and that he was being cooperative." 

And then the story took a turn... 

"Standby for a MAJOR development in the Jussie Smollett case," ABC 7 Chicago reporter Rob Eglas tweeted on Feb. 14, 2019. And major it was. In a subsequent post, Eglas claimed multiple sources were saying that the actor "staged the attack – allegedly because his character was being written out of the show Empire." More reports pointing a finger at Smollett soon emerged, but Chicago Police initially pushed back, tweeting that the reports of a hoax were "unconfirmed by case detectives" and insisting that ABC 7 Chicago's "supposed CPD sources are uninformed and inaccurate."

The conversations brothers Olabinjo and Abimbola Osundairo had with police reportedly sent Jussie Smollett's curious case in an entirely new direction. "Case Update: Due to new evidence as a result of today's interrogations, the individuals questioned by police in the Empire case have now been released without charging and detectives have additional investigative work to complete," Chicago PD spokesman Anthony Guglielmi tweeted on Feb. 15, 2019. In a follow-up statement (per The New York Times), Guglielmi confirmed that the results of the questioning had "shifted the trajectory of the investigation."

According to TMZ, law enforcement sources claimed Smollett agreed to "sign complaints against the 2 men who attacked him," but when he found out the Osundairo brothers "were the ones in custody," the actor allegedly declined.

When Jussie Smollett landed in Chicago shortly after midnight on the night of the alleged attack, the Daily Mail reported that the actor was returning from New York City, where he'd auditioned for a possible revival production of Take Me Out. In the Tony Award-winning play "about a biracial baseball star who comes out as gay," there's reportedly a scene where the lead character suffers an attack that's eerily familiar to the one Smollett described to police — the antagonist in the play also screams "'f****t' and 'n****r” to the baseball player.

Smollett's return flight to Chicago was reportedly delayed. During his wait, the Empire star began posting Instagram stories. An insider told the Daily Mail that investigators allegedly believe the social media posts were shared to "alert" brother Ola and Abel Osundairo.

On Feb. 20, 2019, Jussie Smollett was charged in connection with alleged attack against him. "Felony criminal charges have been approved by @CookCountySAO against Jussie Smollett for Disorderly Conduct / Filing a False Police Report. Detectives will make contact with his legal team to negotiate a reasonable surrender for his arrest," Chicago PD spokesman Anthony Guglielmi tweeted.

On Feb. 21, 2019, Jussie Smollett turned himself in and was placed under arrest. Unfortunately, this incident wasn't the first time Smollett allegedly provided false information to police. According to the New York Post, Smollett once "pleaded no contest in 2007 to providing false information to police during a DUI stop" in Los Angeles. In the misdemeanor complaint, authorities say the Empire actor "gave the name of his brother, Jake, when he was asked by an officer." Smollett eventually accepted a plea deal and was "sentenced to two years' probation" and "completed an alcohol education and treatment program."

After being released on $100,000 bail, Jussie Smollett "went directly" to the Empire set. Once there, per CNN, the actor reportedly apologized to the cast and crew of the hit drama "for any embarrassment the recent allegations may have caused." However, according to sources inside the meeting, Smollett maintained his innocence and blamed the "legal system and the media" for his predicament, leaving everyone in attendance "shocked and dismayed." 

However, according to TMZ, Smollett's apology didn't work. Some of his fellow castmates were reportedly "f**king furious" that he "damaged the show's image" and demanded he be "written off immediately." Apparently, the producers agreed. In a statement (via CNBC), they said they'd opted to "remove the role of 'Jamal' from the final two episodes of the season" in order to avoid further disruption on set."

As of this writing, time is running out for Smollett to reclaim his role, because on May 13, 2019, Variety reported that the sixth season of the music industry drama would be its last. During conference call with reporters after the news broke, Fox Entertainment C.E.O. Charlie Collier dodged questions about Smollett's return. "Oh gosh," Collier said (via Vanity Fair). "You know, really, the [writers'] room hasn't even gathered yet. So we have the option to [bring Smollett back], but there are no plans at this point." At the time of this writing, over 14,000 fans have signed a petition to urge producers to allow Smollett to return.

Outside the courthouse in late March 2019, Jussie Smollett touted his innocence. "Not for a moment was it in vain," Smollett said (via ABC7 Chicago). "I have been truthful and consistent on every single level since day one. I would not be my mother's son if I was capable of one drop of what I was accused of." However, First Assistant State's Attorney Joseph Magats made it clear that he feels very differently. "We believe he did what he was charged with doing," Magats told ABC7 Chicago.

If trying to figure out what's happened has caused your brain to melt, don't worry, you're not alone. Gil Soffer, a former federal prosecutor and legal analyst for ABC7, feels your pain. "It's the very same authority that decided to bring charges in the first place that has now decided to drop those charges," he said, adding that it "doesn't make sense." Even 2020 Democratic presidential candidate and former prosecutor Kamala Harris has no idea what's going on here. "To be perfectly honest ... I'm completely confused..." she told CNN's Wolf Blitzer. "I'm at a loss."

President Donald Trump even tweeted his two cents: "FBI & DOJ to review the outrageous Jussie Smollett case in Chicago. It is an embarrassment to our Nation!" ABC7 Chicago reported that the "FBI is reviewing the circumstances surrounding the dismissal of criminal charges." According to TMZ, the Chicago Fraternal Order of Police filed a complaint with the Department of Justice.

Chicago city officials are demanding Jussie Smollett pay back the cost of the investigation. "The City of Chicago will be sending Mr. Smollett a bill," Police Department spokesman Anthony Guglielmi said (via Page Six). "It was an extensive investigation that required a lot of review of cameras. There was technical assistance provided by external agencies, but it'll likely only include Chicago expenses and not expenses incurred by the FBI and other technical experts we brought in for analysis." Per the Associated Press, the $130,000 bill "covers overtime worked by more than two dozen detectives and officers who spent weeks looking into Smollett's claim, including reviewing video and physical evidence and conducting interviews."

USA Today reports that Chicago's Department of Law sent a letter to Smollett threatening to file a lawsuit to collect even more if the full $130,000 "is not timely paid." Mayor Rahm Emanuel added, "When (Smollett) does pay the city back on just what the taxpayers have fronted, in that memo section (of the check), he can write, 'I'm sorry, and I'm accountable for what I've done.'"

In a statement (via USA Today), Smollett's legal team immediately pushed back on the city's claim that Smollett should be on the hook for the investigation's cost: "It is the Mayor and the Police Chief who owe Jussie — owe him an apology — for dragging an innocent man's character through the mud. Jussie has paid enough."

According to the Chicago Tribune, Cook County Judge Michael Toomin decided that when Cook County State's Attorney Kim Foxx recused herself from the Jussie Smollett case, she had no legal authority hand it over to another prosecutor in her office. Toomin concluded that the case was mishandled and ordered an investigation into "the sudden dismissal" of the 16 felony counts against Smollett.

"Here, the ship of the State ventured from its protected harbor without the guiding hand of the captain," Toomin wrote in his decision. "There was no master on the bridge to guide the ship as it foundered through unchartered waters. And it ultimately lost its bearings." The decision is a win for former state appellate judge Sheila O'Brien, who called for a special prosecutor when the charges were dropped. "We'll get the truth, the whole truth, under oath, and that's what this is about," she told reporters.

Foxx claimed her office remained on the case because didn't recuse herself "in a legal sense," but Toomin shot that reasoning down. "What was intended by Ms. Foxx, and what indeed occurred, was an unconditional legal recusal," he wrote. "Essentially, she announced that she was giving up all of the authority or power she possessed as the duly elected chief prosecutor; she was no longer involved." In simple terms, when Foxx stepped away from the case, her entire office was obligated to step away as well.

According to ABC7, the Chicago Police Department released "nearly 70 hours of video" connected to the Smollett case, including bodycam footage of officers arriving at the actor's apartment. Footage of the Osundairo brothers arriving at the scene of the alleged attack, and "being detained by police at O'Hare International Airport" was also included. 

However, the critical piece of footage shows the officers arriving at Smollett's apartment with his manager, where they found the Empire star still wearing the noose around his neck. Smollett then removes it and asks the officers to stop filming once he realizes they are recording. "He doesn't want this to be a big deal, you understand what I'm saying," Smollett's manager says in the video. "The thing that makes me emotional is they put this makeshift loop, what do you call that thing, a noose around his (expletive) neck. I'm sorry, you know. And that is what bothers me, the cut thing doesn't bother me at all. If that makes any sense."

Per TMZ, another video "shows the Osundairo brothers in a taxi" less than an hour before the alleged attack took place, with one of the brothers "wearing a ski mask." Once they step out of the vehicle, the brothers "don't appear to be holding anything — no noose, no bags — that might be used for the alleged attack on Jussie."

A federal judge allowed the City of Chicago's lawsuit against Jussie Smollett to proceed in late October 2019. According to Variety, Federal Judge Virginia M. Kendall refused to dismiss the case based on the actor's claim that he should not have to pay the combined $390,000 in damages and overtime costs since he didn't realize his hate crime report would be taken that seriously by police.

Smollett's reasoning for trying to get the lawsuit dismissed was decimated by Kendall, who ruled the investigation was a "natural, ordinary, and reasonable consequence of a police report" that claimed racist and homophobic attackers "invoked the President of the United States' official campaign slogan." Are you ready for the zinger? "Smollett contends that police overtime pay is not 'foreseeable in the normal course of events,'" Kendall continued, "but this is hardly the normal course of events — most crime victims, for instance, do not have the opportunity to discuss the crime on Good Morning America." Yikes.

The City of Chicago contended that Smollett should pay for the cost of the investigation under their False Statements Ordinance, and the judge ultimately argued that the actor's attorneys attempted to "muddy the waters with irrelevant arguments." While the city must still prove he filed a false police report, this decision was quite a blow for Smollett. However, one of his attorneys later told CNN, "Mr. Smollett is confident that once the full story is available he will be vindicated."

In his first interview since the legal aftermath of the alleged incident began, Jussie Smollett continued to maintain his innocence, claiming that any suggestion that he perpetrated a hate crime hoax was "bulls**t." Appearing on Instagram with CNN contributor Marc Lamont Hill on Sept. 10, 2020, the former Empire star noted, "What happened in these last two years, it has humbled me in a way that nobody could possibly understand." He added, "Out of all these jokers in this entire situation, I am the only human being who has not changed his story one time." 

Smollett went on to say that the narrative that he was behind the racist and homophobic attack was "intentionally created" to make the public believe he was "lying about something or everything." Insisting that the investigation was a "farce," he said that there were witnesses who could back up his initial claim that two white men attacked him, but alleged that the surveillance footage had been cut or edited. "These are the things that people don't necessarily know because the lies and the things that were not true were yelled from the rooftop," the actor added. "There is a tape ... but of course, it cuts off right before it happens."

"There would be no reason for me to do something like this. There would be no reason for me to do something foolish," Smollett concluded. "... This is bulls**t. It's bulls**t."