Marshals Star Arielle Kebbel's Relationship History Is Full Of Familiar Faces

Arielle Kebbel lives an adrenaline-filled life as Deputy U.S. Marshal Belle Skinner on TV, but her life behind the scenes quieted down a lot in 2026. As of this writing, the "Marshals" star has no real-life partner, having revealed early in the year that she had reverted her relationship status back to single. Even though she has been linked to several familiar faces throughout career, she decided to use the quiet time to focus on herself. "Now I'm in a place of really leaning into my own life choices, I feel like probably for the first time in my life," she said on the "Off the Vine with Kaitlyn Bristowe" podcast in February 2026.

It has been a journey, filled with ups and downs. "I don't think I was really ready to get to know myself in [this] way," she revealed. During this transitional period in her early 40s, Kebbel began trying to untangle her priorities and reorganize what's really important to her. "What do I need to explore to really change patterns for myself in the future, for my heart, for my soul, for what I want moving forward?" she said.

Kebbel is grateful for the transformation because she was never able to be fully honest with herself until this point. It's unclear what the future holds for her love life, but she had previously expressed a desire to settle down. "At some point I want a family. I feel being a film producer and more behind-the-camera will help to give me more control over my schedule than I have today," she told Bedford & New Canaan Magazine in 2023. Kebbel has been in relationships with high-profile men, though none of them has endured the test of time.

Making "Vampire Diaries" fans' hearts explode with joy, Arielle Kebbel's relationship with Zach Roerig came to light at a fan convention in Covington, Georgia, in April 2026, when fans shared a video of Roerig surprising her with flowers before they shared a kiss. "I meet this woman, I fall in love with her, and I get to work with her," Roerig tells fans, to a resounding collective "Aw." However, the timeline of their romance is a bit blurry. 

After working together briefly on the teen hit series in 2009 and then again 2017, Kebbel and the Hallmark hunk reconnected on the set of the 2023 film "Love in the Great Smoky Mountains: A National Park Romance." In September 2024, they attended a screening of the short film series "Window to the West" in New York City in which they looked very much like a couple, as seen above. It appears to be the only high-profile event they attended together. Following their steamy kiss at the convention, Kebbel and Roerig remained on the down low.

Kebbel revealed she and Roerig had broken up in the February 2026 interview on "Off the Vine with Kaitlyn Bristowe" podcast. "I haven't been in a relationship in quite some time," she told Bristowe. What exactly she means by "quite some time" is unclear, but it suggests they split still in 2025. She didn't go into details, but the actor implied there was a lot of heartbreak involved. "It was one of the hardest things I've ever done," she shared.

In 2018, Arielle Kebbel struck up a romance with polo player Nic Roldan, with whom she shares her passion for horses. That September, the Argentina-born athlete moved back to his homeland to play in the South American country — which dominates the sport. The move was temporary, as Roldan expected to return to the U.S., where he was raised, the following December. But he admitted the distance was a complicated factor in the relationship. 

When he relocated to Buenos Aires, Kebbel and Roldan had been dating for just a short time. The polo player worried about the distance at such a vulnerable stage of their romance. "It's not easy. It's still very new — we've only been dating for three months — but obviously it's hard," he told Argentina's Infobae in a November 2018 interview in Spanish. Their plan was to see each other at least every month, with whoever had more time making the effort to go see whoever was busiest.

At the time, Kebbel was shooting "Midnight, Texas," which complicated things. "Now that she just premiered a series, she's swamped and can't come, so I'm going to visit her for four days," he said. The world of polo requires players to travel frequently for open tournaments, so his reality wasn't going to change anytime soon. "The hardest part is the beginning — if we make it through this, we're set!" he said. Unfortunately, it doesn't seem like they managed. It's unclear when they broke up, but it doesn't look like it lasted much at all. 

In the early 2010s, Arielle Kebbel was in a relationship with Aaron Bay-Schuck, who has been the CEO of Warner Records since 2017. During their relationship, Bay-Schuck became president of A&R at Interscope Geffen A&M, where he worked with the likes of Gwen Stefani, Imagine Dragons, Lady Gaga, Lana Del Ray, Maroon 5, MGK, and Selena Gomez — to name a few. There aren't many public details of their relationship, but they attended several high-profile events together starting in 2012.

The last time they were seen together at a big event seems to have been the gala hosted by Art of Elysium and Samsung Galaxy at Hangar 8 in January 2015, seen above. It's unclear when they broke up, with some sources establishing 2016 as the date. What we know is that by 2017, Bay-Schuck was already in a relationship with Hannah Montgomery, a fellow music executive whom he married in November 2020. But while it lasted, Kebbel and Bay-Schuck's relationship appeared serious.

Beautiful day at the crib celebrating my mom's 70th bday with @ArielleKebbel, @TheRealNimoy, family and great friends pic.twitter.com/MOpGMiZ0dO

— Aaron Bay-Schuck (@bayschuck) March 9, 2013

In 2013, Kebbel was next to Bay-Schuck and his family when they gathered to celebrate his mother, a moment he marked on X with a picture of the two together (seen above). "Beautiful day at the crib celebrating my mom's 70th bday with @ArielleKebbel, @TheRealNimoy, family and great friends," he wrote, also tagging his late stepfather, Leonard Nimoy. When he was appointed president of Interscope Geffen A&M Records in 2014, he highlighted his then-girlfriend's support. "@ArielleKebbel my #1 fan :-)," he posted. 

Toward the end of her "Gilmore Girls" days, Arielle Kebbel paired up with film producer Brahman Turner. Like most of her relationships, the timeline here isn't super clear. However, the two attended several Hollywood events between 2004 and 2006, giving some idea of when they were together. They made their debut as a couple at the "Mean Girls" premiere in April 2004 (seen above).

Kebbel worked with her then-boyfriend when he directed her in "Daydreamer," in which she starred alongside Aaron Paul. The film came out in 2007, towards what appears to be the end of the relationship. Not much is known about their romance, other than they appeared to have had a lot of fun at high-profile parties in the mid-aughts. In the picture below, they are seen having a ball up at the record release party for Ashlee Simpson hosted by Mean Magazine in July 2004.

John Sciulli/Getty

Turner has since tied the knot with model Jessica Stam. They got together in 2016, around a decade after he split from Kebbel. They have two children and live in Hawaii.