The real reason Miley and Liam split less than a year after getting married

After just eight months of marriage, Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth called it quits. On Aug. 10, 2019, Cyrus' rep told People in a statement, "Liam and Miley have agreed to separate at this time. Ever-evolving, changing as partners and individuals, they have decided this is what's best while they both focus on themselves and careers. They still remain dedicated parents to all of the animals they share while lovingly taking this time apart. Please respect their process and privacy."

The news came as a shock to the world, as the pair only tied the knot in December 2018 — and seemed blissfully happy. However, the "Mother's Daughter" singer and The Hunger Games star reportedly had issues for a while. An insider told People that the breakup was only shocking to those who didn't personally know the pair, noting, "After they reunited, everyone thought they were this 'perfect' couple, but they still had a lot of issues. They're not on the same page when it comes to a lot of fundamental things that make a relationship work. It's not surprising at all."

So what happened? Here are a few explanations of what doomed this rollercoaster couple.

Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth got married on a whim

Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth both admitted that their decision to get married was somewhat of a whirlwind. After they lost their Malibu, Calif., home in the devastating wildfires that swept the state in 2018, Cyrus told Vanity Fair that they realized it was time to make a move and make their bond permanent. "When you experience what we experienced together with someone, it is like glue. You're the only two people in the world who can understand," she said. She wrote in a personal memo for the magazine that the experience "changed" them. "I'm not sure without losing Malibu, we would've been ready to take this step or ever even gotten married ... but the timing felt right and I go with my heart."

Hemsworth was a bit more lighthearted, telling Extra that the wedding was "a spur-of-the-moment kind of thing," including "mainly immediate family." In Cyrus' lengthy Vanity Fair profile, she admitted to being very carpe diem, noting, "No one is promised the next day, or the next, so I try to be 'in the now' as much as possible. If I ever find myself thinking too far ahead, I acknowledge that anxiety and bring myself back into my body and out of my head." That said, she and Hemsworth were engaged for at least two years when they finally took the plunge, so it's not like it was completely out of left field.

Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth were on-again off-again forever

Despite being seemingly rock-solid for the years leading up to their marriage, Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth's relationship was a rocky one for around a decade before that. After meeting on the set of The Last Song in 2009, they split in summer 2010, but reunited not long afterward. By June 2012, they'd confirmed their engagement to People, but weren't in a rush down the aisle. In fact, in early 2013, Cyrus was spotted without her engagement ring, leading to split rumors that she later denied. By that April, sources told People the wedding was off, but that she and Hemsworth still lived together and remained engaged ... until September 2013, when they confirmed the engagement was off. Right around that time, Hemsworth was snapped making out with actress Eiza Gonzalez; in 2014 he was rumored to be dating Vampire Diaries star Nina Dobrev.

From 2014 through much of 2015, Cyrus rebounded, first with Patrick Schwarzenegger, then with model Stella Maxwell. By that November, there were rumblings that she and Hemsworth were back together, and those rumblings grew louder after she was spotted in his family's social media posts in early 2016. In 2017, Cyrus confirmed to Billboard that her song "Malibu" was about Hemsworth, and that they were back together. Since then, they've been — at least until the split news broke — relatively stable, although Cyrus felt forced to yet again deny breakup rumors in June 2019.

Was there a conflict over kids?

It's a tale as old as time (and one that fellow stars like Jennifer Aniston are sick of hearing): Boy meets girl, boy marries girl, boy wants kids, girl is like, "Wait, I want to live a full life without being a vessel for your genes just yet," boy and girl split. A few reports have suggested that's what happened with Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth. In the May/June 2019 issue of GQ Australia, Hemsworth admitted that while he and Cyrus wanted "10, 15, maybe 20 kids" eventually, the newlyweds weren't in a rush to breed and brood just yet.

Sources told Radar Online in July 2019 that the couple planned to rebuild their new home on the same plot of land as the Malibu mansion they shared before it burned down, and that they were intent on raising children there once everything settled down. However, shortly after the split news broke, an insider told the site, "He wanted babies, and she just didn't anymore."

Fame may have hurt Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth's marriage

Insiders told People that the normally low-key Liam Hemsworth may have struggled with Miley Cyrus' fame and the pressures associated with it, especially during her twerking, "Wrecking Ball" era. A source explained, "When they got engaged the first time, they were just kids. There was no way they were ready for that kind of commitment. ... Miley was a bit lost and wanted to break out of that [Disney] image. Liam's career was also blowing up with Hunger Games, and they were being pulled a million different ways. He didn't know how to handle the attention and drama."

However, it seemed like the pair had it all figured out once they reconciled, with Us Weekly reporting that Cyrus became a bit of a June Cleaver type after their 2015 reunion in hopes of keeping Hemsworth around. "Liam never liked that she got crazy, so Miley's making big changes," the insider said, adding, "She doesn't want to screw it up." Insiders also claimed that he was annoyed with her 2019 Met Gala antics, which reportedly included "grinding on people" and "licking his face," with a source saying he "really doesn't like that side of her."

Cyrus also blabbed to Howard Stern (via E! News) in December 2018 that Hemsworth got "a lot of action" for rescuing their pets during the Woolsey Fire, and added that they regularly engage in "cybersex" via FaceTime. She also boasted of his bedroom prowess on Instagram.

It might just be the most boring reason ever

Call it the Occam's razor rule, but often the simplest explanation is the one most likely to be true. If that's the case, then Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth may have simply grown apart due to distance spent away from one another for work and other commitments. 

A source explained to E! News that they'd been "drifting apart" and trying to work out their differences for a while before calling it quits. "They have been trying to make it work for months now but haven't felt they were connecting on the level they were feeling when they got married last year," the source said, adding, "It's been a rough year." The source noted that Hemsworth wanted a lowkey, homebody lifestyle to which they'd gotten accustomed, whereas Cyrus was eager to go on tour and release new music, which takes her away from home often, pointing out that she's been spending a lot of time in Europe.

Miley Cyrus can't be tamed

Miley Cyrus was reportedly "ecstatic" to marry Liam Hemsworth ... until the realities of traditional marriage set in, which reportedly sent her running for the hills. Cyrus explained to Elle in July 2019, "I mean, do people really think that I'm at home in a f**king apron cooking dinner? I'm in a hetero relationship, but I still am very sexually attracted to women." She added, "I made a partner decision. This is the person I feel has my back the most. I definitely don't fit into a stereotypical wife role. I don't even like that word." She also told Vanity Fair that being queer was a big part of her own identity, and claimed that she and Hemsworth were "redefining" heterosexual marriage, but didn't specify how.

Now, there may be a clue. Sources close to the singer allege that part of what led to the demise of their young union was Cyrus' fear of being tied down. An insider told Radar Online that Cyrus was the one who pulled the plug on the brief marriage, explaining, "She said she wanted an open relationship. She wasn't ready for just one person for forever."

Wait, was Miley Cyrus so wild that she was actually adulterous?

A big part of the couple's issues was that Liam Hemsworth allegedly wanted Miley Cyrus to be a bit more domesticated. Guess how well that turned out? A source told Entertainment Tonight, "Liam loves Miley and it made him feel sad and a bit insecure when she openly talked about her attraction to other people. In the end, he didn't know how to control the situation and she didn't want to be controlled." The source also said that while Cyrus believes people should be "open and fluid," Hemsworth "wanted a more conventional marriage." Another insider told the outlet in a separate report that Cyrus wanted to explore her sexuality more. 

As such, a source told TMZ that Cyrus' alleged infidelity was the reason the couple's marriage ended. Although no details were given about any cheating accusations specifically, a source close to the singer denied to Page Six that cheating had anything to do with the breakup. "Miley was not unfaithful, and all these stories about her being wild and cheating is a bunch of bulls** t," the source said. "They split up. She's taking the high road. Everyone is trying to. They were together since she was 16. It's hard."

Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth have a history of codependency

After Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth's first big breakup in 2013 — but before their marital separation in August 2019 — she admitted that they had codependent tendencies in their relationship, which led to their split. "I had to [break up]. I don't like when relationships are two halves trying to make a whole. So I don't think I have that codependency. I think people that break up and get back together, that's awesome," she told The Howard Stern Show (via Billboard). "You get time to be yourself. You get time to grow up. I think if you're growing up attached to another person, you never really get solid as your own being." 

Cyrus also explained in Vanity Fair, "My relationship is very special to me, it is my home. I feel less misplaced when we are in the same room, no matter where that is, but just because something changes in my relationship doesn't mean something has to drastically change in my individuality."

Miley Cyrus may not have trusted Liam Hemsworth

Insiders admitted shortly after Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth tied the knot that they had issues prior to the marriage, and those issues may have come back to haunt them after walking down the proverbial aisle in her Tennessee home. "Miley went through a lot of soul-searching as she grew up and became her own person," one source told People. Another added, "Miley had trust issues and Liam felt she was needy. After years, they finally figured out ways to meet halfway and respectfully deal with each other's differences."

Those trust issues may have come from Hemsworth's alleged infidelity during the more tumultuous times in their relationship before they tied the knot. Us Weekly reported in September 2013 — right after they called off their engagement — that Hemsworth hooked up with January Jones that February, while he and Cyrus were still together, though Hemsworth and Jones denied it.

Has Miley Cyrus already moved on with Kaitlynn Carter?

The night before Miley Cyrus and Liam Hemsworth announced they were separating, photos were published of her with Brody Jenner's ex, Kaitlynn Carter (above), kissing and canoodling on vacation in Italy. (Jenner and Carter split just weeks before Cyrus and Hemsworth announced their own separation.) A source told People that Carter and Cyrus share mutual friends and are "just having fun." 

However, a witness told Entertainment Tonight that Carter and Cyrus weren't trying to be discreet at all, dishing that they were in full view of everyone at the pool. "They were fully on a date, getting drinks, just the two of them," the spy revealed. "They even got a couple of massages at the hotel." Another spy told E! News, "They were never far from each other and every few minutes they would pull each other in close and make out under their hats. They seemed to be having a lot of fun together and fully letting loose. They couldn't keep their hands off of each other. They pulled their chairs closer together and would reach across to hold hands or put their arms around each other." What's more, the Daily Mail reported that Cyrus has been spotted without her ring more often than not in recent months.

Does Liam Hemsworth's family dislike Miley Cyrus?

Some reports have claim that Liam Hemsworth's family isn't a huge fan of Miley Cyrus. Sources told Us Weekly that Hemsworth's brothers, Chris and Luke, staged an intervention to get Liam to end their engagement in April 2013. Another source told OK! Australia (via the Mirror) after their separation in August 2019, "[Cyrus] didn't really want to get married. It's something that everyone else seemed to get but Liam. [His] family had been begging him to see the light for a long time, but he had faith in Miley. Now he feels like an idiot." An insider also told Radar Online that Hemsworth is "heartbroken" by Cyrus' apparent rebound romance with Carter, adding that "his family cannot believe she is flaunting this for the world to see. They think she's a disgrace."

An insider pointed out to The Sun that Cyrus and Hemsworth keep using the term "separated" but not "divorcing," and sources close to the actor say that worries his brood, who are concerned they'll reunite and start the cycle over again. "They think Liam should cut Miley off and can't stand the idea of them getting back together. Nobody wants that," the insider said.

Is Miley Cyrus rubbing her antics in Liam Hemsworth's face on purpose?

For her part, Miley Cyrus is taking the split in stride, flaunting her new romance and her abs all over Instagram. Echoing her rep's statement about "evolving," Cyrus wrote on Instagram, "Don't fight evolution, because you will never win. Like the mountain I am standing on top of, which was once underwater, connected with Africa, change is inevitable. The Dolomites were not created overnight, it was over millions of years that this magnificent beauty was formed." She continued, "My dad always told me, 'Nature never hurries but it is always on time.' ... it fills my heart with peace and hope KNOWING that is true. I was taught to respect the planet and its process and I am committed to doing the same with my own."

Hemsworth is reportedly "heartbroken" that she's moving on so quickly with Kaitlynn Carter, but not everyone buys that their hookup is real. Insiders told Entertainment Tonight that Cyrus and Carter aren't serious about one another, and Brandon Thomas Lee (Brody Jenner's co-star on The Hills: New Beginnings) told The Daily Pop that he thinks the entire romance is simply a way for Cyrus and Carter to troll their exes.

There were allegations of substance abuse

Miley Cyrus has made it no secret that she really loves marijuana, but TMZ reported that she and Liam Hemsworth feuded over alleged drug use. Sources told the site that Cyrus had an issue with Hemsworth's alleged drinking and "using certain drugs," though the drugs in question weren't specified. A member of Hemsworth's camp denied the drug allegations, griping, "This is another attempt by Miley to distract from her infidelity and recent outrageous public behavior."

An insider told People that Cyrus' concerns may have been at least somewhat valid, concurring, "Everyone always thinks Miley is problematic and immature and a hardcore partier while he's this chill surfer dude, but that's actually [not accurate]. Liam parties with his friends, and Miley thinks he should've grown out of that by now." 

In what could be a reference to this very issue, Cyrus released a new song, "Slide Away," on Aug. 16, 2019, that includes lyrics like, "I want my house in the hills / Don't want the whiskey and pills / I don't give up easily but I don't think I'm down / Move on, we're not 17 / I'm not who I used to be / You said that everything changed / You're right, we're grown now." Of course, it's purely speculative about whom the track was written, but the timing is either really uncanny or deliberately shady. In any case, a source denied to Page Six that Hemsworth had a drinking problem.

Liam Hemsworth got fed up and filed for divorce

And then came the "Wrecking Ball" for real: On Aug. 21, 2019, TMZ reported that Liam Hemsworth filed for divorce from Miley Cyrus, hiring celebrity "disso queen" Laura Wasser to represent him in the split; Hemsworth claimed "irreconcilable differences" as the reason for the divorce, but no date of separation has yet been listed. Sources claimed that the couple had a prenuptial agreement, and since they didn't have kids (save for their pets), the division of property in their divorce settlement should be a relatively simple one. Insiders also claimed that Cyrus was desperate to make it work with the Aussie actor, and "made overtures" to him even while she was reportedly getting publicly wild with rebound fling Kaitlynn Carter, but that he refused to reunite with her, saying he was "over the marriage."

Sources concurred to People that Cyrus may not have wanted to end things for good, explaining that she "isn't trying to hurt him" amid the separation, while Us Weekly also reported that Cyrus really wanted to make their marriage go the distance.

Miley Cyrus can't stop, won't stop feeding the tabloids

After Liam Hemsworth filed for divorce from Miley Cyrus, she spoke out on Twitter to blast allegations that she cheated. In an 11-tweet thread and matching Instagram post, Cyrus referenced many of her previous tabloid scandals, which she claimed cost her business opportunities. She even confessed to cheating in relationships when she was younger, but she insisted, "The truth is, once Liam & I reconciled, I meant it, & I was committed. There are NO secrets to uncover here. I've learned from every experience in my life. I'm not perfect, I don't want to be, it's boring. I've grown up in front of you, but the bottom line is, I HAVE GROWN UP."

"I can admit to a lot of things but I refuse to admit that my marriage ended because of cheating," she continued. "Liam and I have been together for a decade. I've said it before & it remains true, I love Liam and always will." She went on to discuss her outspoken love for cannabis and twerking and said she had to "make a healthy decision" to leave her past life behind.

Ironically, Cyrus' publicity-hounding is reportedly why Hemsworth filed for divorce. A source explained to Entertainment Tonight, "At first, Liam wanted to just give it time but he finally felt like things were getting nasty and he didn't want to drag it out publicly. He decided it was all too much."