According To Fans, These Are The Worst Episodes Of Glee

Add Nicki Swift on Google:
Google Discover

For six seasons, "Glee" was a juggernaut of pop culture television. While some "Glee" characters missed the mark from the get-go, the fervor over "Glee" still seems to be alive and kicking more than a decade after its series finale. In October 2026, Disney+ and Hulu announced a reboot of the series with original creators Ryan Murphy, Ian Brennan, and Brad Falchuk at the helm. Needless to say, fans were sent into a frenzy akin to the Tumblr riots of days past — for better or worse. As fans reminisce over the history-making show, they've also been quick to admit that not all episodes have aged gracefully.

From culturally insensitive storylines to the occasional racist undertone, many have found certain episodes of the original series to be among the worst created. But that hasn't stopped them from exhibiting the same sort of curious excitement that even the cast members he'd spoken with experienced, according to Murphy. "They've all had a lot of questions, but they all were very enthusiastic about the idea," he shared with Entertainment Tonight.

Sadie Hawkins (Season 4, Episode 11)

Season 4 was a rough transition period for "Glee" cast and fans alike. With the original graduates of McKinley High out of the choir room, a new group of performers emerged to earn their glee club ranks to mixed success. With former Dalton Academy Warbler Blaine (Darren Criss) now part of the New Directions — and his longtime love Kurt (Chris Colfer) away in New York — his leading man status became fodder for more than one admirer. In "Sadie Hawkins," that admirer was misguided gal pal Tina (Jenna Ushkowitz), who ends up asking Blaine to the dance, unaware that he has a crush on Sam. Meanwhile, the new crop of New Directions were busy sabotaging each other's relationships and hooking up with former glee clubbers (looking at you, Kitty and Puck).

All in all, even a spirited rendition of "No Scrubs" at the namesake dance couldn't save this episode from making the worst-ranked list. Fans and critics alike were quick to lament the episode — going so far as to give it a 7.1 rating on IMDB and making it one of the show's lowest-scoring episodes — for providing way too many out-of-character moments for Tina and the gang. "Glee is a show that thinks it's fly, but sometimes the plots strain even the show's own unique world and logic," reviewer Erin Strecker wrote for EW at the time.

Shooting Star (Season 4, Episode 18)

Another Season 4 episode, "Shooting Star," attempted to venture into drama territory but, at least according to fans, fell flat on its message. The episode depicts the real-time reaction to a school shooting: Mr. Schuester (Matthew Morrison) and Coach Beiste (Dot-Marie Jones) barricaded the choir room and instructed students to hide; cheerleader Brittany (Heather Morris) hid in a bathroom and sobbed while standing on top of a toilet; and students filmed videos of themselves for loved ones in case they didn't survive. But the seriousness of the episode was countered by the fact that this event accounted for less than half of the overall story before diving back into its regular plot points.

To make matters worse, some even criticized the "reveal" of the school shooter at the climax of the episode. "It's also really not okay that 'Glee' chose to make the sole character with Down syndrome the shooter (even if she didn't have nefarious intentions)," critic Lauren Hoffman wrote for Vulture. The episode also aired just four months after the tragic mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School that claimed 26 lives. While the episode managed an 8.5 IMDB rating, many fans were still wary that this was a program equipped to handle such delicate topics. "I don't think 'Glee' is very good at handling serious traumatic things [and] this episode shows that," one user shared on Reddit.

Lights Out (Season 4, Episode 20)

Another Season 4 standout (for all the wrong reasons) was "Lights Out," which saw the glee club going unplugged when McKinley High loses power. While the musical performances seemed on par for the show, it was the fumbling of yet another serious subject that incensed fans. After a stirring rendition of R.E.M.'s "Everybody Hurts," new kid Ryder (Blake Jenner) revealed that he was molested by his babysitter when he was younger. In turn, several of his classmates brushed off his claims and called it "every teenage boy's fantasy." It was these reactions that caused "Glee" fans to speak out online. "Sam and Artie's reaction to Ryder was the most disturbing thing," one user shared on Reddit. "Like, made my stomach sick. Wow."

What seemed to incense fans and critics alike the most, though, was that this was another example of "Glee" mishandling serious subjects in favor of dramatic whiplash between its realistic and whimsical moments. While Ryder was revealing his secret to his classmates, ex-Glee clubbers Kurt, Rachel (Lea Michele), and Santana (Naya Rivera) were literally singing "At The Ballet" in a dream sequence-esque montage alongside Sarah Jessica Parker. "Ryder's trauma can't help but overwhelm an episode that would rather, if the opulent direction is any indication, reminisce about the ballet than seriously confront this pain," Brandon Nowalk wrote for AV Club. The episode holds a 7.0 IMDB rating, making it one of the lowest-scoring episodes of the season.

A Katy or a Gaga (Season 5, Episode 4)

By the time "Glee" entered Season 5, the show was arguably on its last legs, and many believe it had something to do the untimely passing of actor Cory Monteith. The first episode following the tribute to the fallen Finn (Monteith) was likely always going to be awkward, especially given the gravitas of Monteith's death. But few anticipated just how awkward it would get when "A Katy or a Gaga" aired on their screens, showcasing Mr. Schuester splitting the club into Katy Perry and Lady Gaga factions and challenging each group to perform in the other artist's style. Cue the over-the-top performances of "Applause" in full Gaga garb and a jungle-set rendition of "Roar" complete with an actual rope swing on stage (yes, really.) Fans were taken aback by the elaborateness of the episode — and for "Glee," that's saying something. "Their choice of costumes for some scenes were pretty awkward to watch," one fan admitted on Reddit. "This would be acceptable on cable, but I'm actually SHOCKED that this was approved by Fox."

The audience rating reflected this sentiment, as it currently has an average 7.2 rating on IMDB. Some were still able to find levity within the otherwise stunted episode. "If anyone managed to count the number of times the words 'Katy' or 'Gaga' were said on tonight's episode, please submit your findings for scientific study," Marc Snetiker wrote in an EW review.

The End of Twerk (Season 5, Episode 5)

Many would think things couldn't get worse following "A Katy or a Gaga," but things definitely could. Episode 5 of Season 5, "The End of Twerk," is widely regarded as one of the most polarizing episodes in "Glee" history. The highest point of cringe occurs when Mr. Schuester leads his students in a merry twerk-a-thon through the hallways of McKinley High set to Robin Thicke's "Blurred Lines." (Yes, dear reader, it is as inappropriate and tone deaf as it sounds.) "When this show is about teens, it's weird to see overly sexual stuff happen with them," one Reddit user posted. That sentiment is reflected in its dismal IMDB rating of 6.0, among the show's lowest.

Others looked past the actual act and questioned the lack of meaning behind Schuester's "lesson" of the week. Critic Marc Snetiker summed things up succinctly by referring to the pivotal performance as "a married 37-year-old singing a song about date rape with nine minors down the halls of a public high school" (via EW). Schuester's response? He claimed it was his First Amendment right to lead the twerk parade. Chalk this one up to an episode best left in "Glee's" rearview mirror.

Previously Unaired Christmas (Season 5, Episode 8)

As far as ratings go, Season 5's "Previously Unaired Christmas" is about as low as they go, tying "The End of Twerk" with an abysmal 6.0. From fans and critics to cast members themselves, the holiday-themed hour has aged so poorly that there is little in the episode that could probably air today. "We knew it was very offensive," actor Jenna Ushkowitz shared on the "And That's What You Really Missed" podcast alongside co-star Kevin McHale (who played Artie). "You had to commit so hard because it was so bad."

In particular, the episode features an array of off-color moments that span from McKinley High in Lima, Ohio, to the bright lights of New York City (there's no place that "Glee" won't offend). While Kitty (played by Becca Tobin) throws racist insults at classmate Unique (Alex Newell) in the choir room, the big city living trio of Kurt, Rachel and Santana take a side gig as holiday elves that ends with Santana sniping at children with anti-Semitic remarks and Kurt being assaulted by a mall Santa. Even by "Glee's" standards, this episode seemed a bit too out of pocket for audiences and cast members alike. And that's just a couple of the episode's most off-putting storylines. "Bad is good when it's funny ... This just felt like being controversial for controversial sake," McHale remarked on the podcast.

Tested (Season 5, Episode 16)

The Season 5 train of mediocre episodes continued with the 7.0 IMDB-rated "Tested," which shows fan favorite couple Kurt and Blaine literally taking their relationship issues out on the dance floor to "Love Is A Battlefield." While we know that Criss's life since "Glee" has resulted in plenty of accolades, this episode was arguably a bit of a stretch for the character that made him a household name. In the episode, Blaine begins to feel lesser than his fiancé, who has become more fit and has gained male attention as a result. Meanwhile, Artie is having a very different sort of testing, as he finds out he contracted an STD after having unprotected sex with three different partners.

While some critics claimed that this era of the show showed a more mature side, others have lamented the mixed messaging and have even called out the quick juxtaposition from high school stories to grown-up issues. "They're really trying to heavily hit us over the head that [the characters] are adults now, they're on their own, and now [there's] all these adult problems that they're facing," fan Marisa Serafini shared with AfterBuzzTV.

The Back-Up Plan (Season 5, Episode 18)

In "The Back-Up Plan" — which currently holds a 6.8 rating on IMDb — even the great Shirley MacLaine couldn't save the episode from being one of "Glee's" worst across six seasons. While Santana and Mercedes debate recording music together and Blaine befriends MacLaine's wealthy socialite character with a duet of "Piece of My Heart," it's Rachel's drama that had fans both outraged and annoyed. For five seasons, the showtune-belting ingénue was keen on becoming a Broadway star, and by this episode, she had her dream role (Fanny Brice in "Funny Girl") in her grasp. But by the episode's end, she puts her series-long dream in jeopardy when she flies to Los Angeles to audition for a TV pilot.

Many fans were split with their thoughts on Rachel's abrupt about-face. Some supported the writers' decision to add more stakes to her storyline, while others lamented that it seemed out of character to ruin her ideal career this quickly. Regardless of which side of the debate they were on, many agreed that at least one aspect of the character remained the same for better or worse. "Oh boy, another episode about Rachel's ego," one user summarized on Reddit.

Recommended