Major DWTS Scandals That Made It Out Of The Ballroom
For a primetime dancing reality competition, it's pretty surprising how many scandals "Dancing With the Stars" has drummed up over the years. But once you take a look at how connected the cast really is — many stars on the show are actually related, a whole lot of pros have fallen in love with each other, and over a dozen pairings have resulted in an offscreen showmance — it's easy to see how this show really creates its own drama outside of the competition. Dancing requires chemistry and passion, after all!
From protestors storming the dance floor to boycotting a celebrity contestant to nasty falls out between pro dancers and their famous partners to an accusation of siblings getting preferential treatment, there are quite a few dramas that have made national news while the show has been airing for over two decades. We're rounding up all the buzziest headlines and filling you in on all the biggest controversies now...
Erin Andrews was accused of rolling her eyes when a contestant proposed on an episode
Over the years, "Dancing With the Stars" has seen its fair share of hosts and co-hosts — and a scandal about cast turnover happened (more on that later), but perhaps no one stepped in it as badly as co-host Erin Andrews in 2015. The former sports reporter, who had competed during S10, officially joined the cast in S18.
But it wasn't until S20 that she found herself in hot water. When contestant Noah Galloway proposed to his girlfriend on an episode that May, Andrews didn't look enthused — and fans clocked her rude reaction right away. US Weekly reported that she looked "more than annoyed" and had been "caught on camera rolling her eyes."
In response to the accusations, the co-host denied any eye roll (despite it being caught on camera) and instead posted an explanation to US Weekly at the time, writing "uhhhhh it's called an oh great I'm going to bawl on camera..ugly cry face alert." She also doubled down on Instagram, posting a screenshot along with a caption, "What a moment...sorry for the ugly cry face debut...love u Noah and Jamie." We guess it's up to the viewers to decide!
Ryan Lochte's bad behavior at the Olympics led to a crazy ballroom protest
It seemed like a match made in heaven — a good-looking Olympian trying his hand at ballroom dancing under the watchful eye of a seasoned pro partner. But when swimmer Ryan Lochte was paired with Cheryl Burke in S23, some "Dancing With the Stars" fans were not happy. They were so unhappy that they stormed the ballroom.
The controversy happened on the premiere episode, when Lochte and Burke received critiques from the judges. Two men ambushed him on the stage, wearing clothes with slogans against the Olympian. The move came in response to his controversial behavior at the Rio 2016 Summer Olympics, where he allegedly exaggerated claims that he was robbed at gunpoint.
Both protesters were arrested for trespassing, with ESPN reporting that one of them was heard calling Lochte a "liar" who shouldn't be "publicized as a star" as he was being taken away by police. According to ESPN, after the incident, the athlete said he "thought it was a joke," adding, "when we realized it wasn't, that hurt, that broke my heart, that people are still on that subject and no one's moving forward."
Brooks Nader and Gleb Savchenko's messy showmance made its way onto another reality show
Showmances between stars and their pro partners are par for the course on "Dancing With the Stars." When Sports Illustrated model Brooks Nader was paired with Gleb Savchenko for S33, sparks flew immediately. Nader later admitted on "Watch What Happens Live" that the duo got intimate on the first day they met.
The star explained to host Andy Cohen that she was newly divorced when they were paired for the reality competition, and curiosity got the best of her, sharing, "There was so much sexual tension on the first day we met that it would just get worse and worse and I just wanted to see what we're working with."
While this chemistry didn't help them much in the ballroom — they came in ninth place that season — it led to a rocky on-again, off-again romance that spawned dozens of headlines and even spiraled into the first season of the model's own TV series, "Love Thy Nader." The demise of their messy entanglement was even caught on camera, as Nader went through Savchenko's phone and discovered that he had been cheating on her on an episode of the Hulu reality show.
Hope Solo accused her partner Maksim Chmerkovskiy of abuse in her memoir
Soccer star Hope Solo tried a different sport in 2011's S13 of "Dancing With the Stars" and was paired with pro Maksim Chmerkovskiy. The duo lasted quite a while, with Solo coming in fourth place, being bad sports in the ballroom. While receiving their scores during their final week, Solo was visibly angry, commenting, "Sevens? The same thing I got in week one. Kiss my booty. The scores at this point, the judges at this point mean nothing" (via Bleacher Report).
But the bad attitude wasn't the scandalous thing to come from Solo's time on the show. A year after she hung up her dancing shoes, she referenced her time on the ABC competition and accused partner Chmerkovskiy of abuse in her 2012 memoir. "He manhandled me in rehearsals from the start, pushing me, whacking my stomach, bending my arms roughly," the athlete wrote, via USA Today.
She also recollected a time he slapped her across the face and said the pro dancer once, "hit my stomach so hard with his open palm that I had a red handprint there for the rest of the day." For his part, Chmerkovskiy took to X, then Twitter, at the time, posting his reaction: "Always hated hypocrites and liars...but when someone is both AND an opportunist, I just feel bad for them. Can't win at someone's expense..." Yikes!
A big hosting shake-up made major news in 2020 when two major stars were fired
For 28 seasons, Tom Bergeron was a steadfast fixture on "Dancing With the Stars" as the host of the reality competition. While co-hosts came and went, the show had found a great combo when Erin Andrews joined the cast in S18. Unfortunately for both hosts, that changed in 2020. That year, ABC and BBC Studios announced that Bergeron and Andrews would not return for S29 — just a few months before the show was due to premiere (via Entertainment Weekly).
A year later, Bergeron opened up about the firing on Bob Saget's "Here For You" podcast, "The show that I left was not the show that I loved." He also explained that it wasn't quite as bittersweet as fans believed, adding, "I wasn't surprised that that was my last season, so there was no blue period. Actually, I think Erin and I had more fun being fired than virtually anybody."
As for Andrews, she didn't take it as optimistically. The star opened up about the firing to Barstool's "Token CEO" podcast, sharing, "I didn't have much time to deal with it ... I felt sorry for myself and I kind of was like, this is a terrible time to lose my job because, you know, we don't know when live television is coming back. These are hard jobs to get."
A fake heiress-turned-'DWTS' star had a wild exit interview during season 33
In a first for the popular ABC series, S33 featured a convicted con woman who had to compete wearing a bedazzled ankle monitor. Anna Delvey, whose real name is Anna Sorokin, already had a fictionalized take on her life stream on Netflix, "Inventing Anna," before signing on to dance with partner Ezra Sosa on "Dancing With the Stars."
The strange casting of a criminal sparked a boycott amongst "DWTS" fans, with one writing, "I am not watching it this season because I am not interested in watching criminals, who hurt people, thrive" and another noting, "Of all the thousands of reality stars and actual celebrities, they decide to give her an extra platform? Super disappointed in this" (via TV Insider).
Despite angry fans, ABC went ahead with Delvey in the cast — and it's no she was of the first two stars eliminated that season. But the alleged fraudster created a buzz with her eviction, as her unbothered attitude raised eyebrows. When host Julianne Hough asked what she would take with her from her experience on the show, Delvey infamously responded, "Nothing."
A season 14 couple had a major fight at rehearsals that almost cost them the competition
In 2012, "Dancing With the Stars" had a massive scandal when one of its pairings got into a physical altercation. Actor Jaleel White and pro Kym Johnson were paired for S14 when a bad rehearsal nearly derailed their time together. US Weekly reported at the time that a rehearsal got heated when White accidentally stepped on Johnson's foot, resulting in the dancer saying "ouch." This reportedly infuriated the "Family Matters" actor, who "got in her face" and yelled at her for "acting like a baby." Sources told the outlet he was "shouting at her" and called her "an idiot."
Things only got worse when fellow stars, pros, and some of the show's producers tried to intervene, as White "started going off on the producers and shouting about how they put him with a 'stupid' partner."
He also got into an altercation with pro Mark Ballas that had to be broken up by producers, per the outlet. White was temporarily banished from the studio, but surprisingly the duo eventually made amends and returned to the ballroom to compete that week. The pair lasted four more weeks before being sent home during week 7. A source close to the show told US Weekly that, for her part, Johnson "has never had a conflict with one of her dance partners before."
Season 27's voting glitch really changed up the standings when phone votes couldn't be counted
Since the start of "Dancing With the Stars," fans have been able to weigh in and keep their favorites in the competition with their votes. But during S27 in 2018, a major snafu changed up the standings. While fans were able to vote via phone or online, a technical glitch led to none of the phone-in votes being counted. That meant the elimination would be left up to the judges' scores and the online voters.
"Entertainment Tonight" caught up with the pair who nearly went home after the show, and they revealed that the lack of phone votes was really unfair for their standings. Actor and country music singer John Schneider, who was paired with pro Emma Slater, told the outlet he was "shocked" by the change, with Slate, explaining, "My reaction was, 'Oh no!' because I think that our audience are primarily phone voters, and I put a lot of effort in yesterday, both of us did, like, 'Hey guys, vote for us,' hoping that they would and knowing that that didn't count, that really shook the ground for me." Fortunately for Schneider and Slater, skier Danielle Umstead ended up going home that night. The pair were sadly eventually eliminated during week 7.
Judge Bruno Tonioli made a very offensive comment to a contestant during season 20
When Charlotte McKinney joined the S20 cast of "Dancing With the Stars," she couldn't have anticipated that one of the judges would insult her. The model and actor was paired with Keo Motsepe after her major success in a "Carl's Jr." commercial. Unfortunately, during McKinney's time on the show, she was judged for more than her dancing.
In week 3, judge Bruno Tonioli let his critiques stray from her moves to her appearance — as he uncomfortably told her, "You're never going to win the Nobel prize for quantum physics, but you are easy on the eyes and you produce wonderful shapes." USA Today reported on the awkward exchange, adding that the crowd booed Tonioli, who immediately apologized — but the damage was done.
To add insult to injury, McKinney was sent home later that night. After being eliminated, she opened up to "Good Morning America" about Tonioli's remarks, stating, "To be honest, I just really thought it was uncalled for. Especially the week before, I've really been trying to be used as a platform for social media bullying and really just stop any negativity and just talk about being positive, and it just came out of nowhere." Despite the comments, McKinney stayed positive, adding, "At the end of the day, just shake it off."
The church of Scientology was the reason for one star and pro pair's major fallout
It was a pairing made in heaven... until it wasn't. Kirstie Alley first competed on S12 of "Dancing With the Stars" and made it to the finals alongside her pro Maksim Chmerkovskiy. The duo had a sweet friendship that lasted beyond the ballroom — so much so that they teamed up again for the All Stars season the following year. Their bond seemed strong until one of Alley's biggest enemies joined the "DWTS" cast.
Leah Remini, a known critic of Alley's church, Scientology, joined S17 of the show, and though she wasn't even paired with pro Chmerkovskiy, the two's newfound friendship was enough to enrage Alley. Chmerkovskiy revealed that this was the reason for the friendship split on "Watch What Happens Live" in 2014, telling host Andy Cohen, "I thought we had a great relationship and if it was something else or not, I don't know. But I got a message that now that I'm associating with other people that she can't be associated with, I am no longer to be spoken with, and sorry, but that is what it is."
The Hough siblings were accused of preferential treatment during season 19
Coincidence ... or preferential treatment? During Julianne Hough's first season as a judge on "Dancing With the Stars," her brother Derek Hough received some pretty high scores, and fans paid attention. It all went down during S19 — Derek was paired with YouTube star Bethany Mota, as Julianne started her first stint as a full-time judge. As he regularly received good scores from his little sister, viewers were not amused.
Julianne spoke to TV Guide about the criticism, revealing the fans had nothing to worry about. "We've definitely called each other out on our stuff. If anything, I might be even harder on him," she told the outlet. She also insisted to E! News that it was no different than judging her fellow pros, explaining, "I'm honestly just as close to Mark [Ballas], and Cheryl [Burke] and Karina Smirnoff... For me going on the show and judging my brother is just like judging anybody else. I judge him every day." Despite her insistence that he didn't receive any favoritism, Derek and Mota came in fourth that season — and their last dance earned them a perfect score.